More Pages: Republic Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90


Good Historical Document

Psychologically inaccurate, but historically helpful.

The continuing story after the last emperor

great book

Strong integrated analysis of post-socialist politicsHowever, the book does have its flaws. One is that Tismaneanu excessively frets over the fate of the former dissidents, like Havel, Konrad or Michnik, who have lost quite a bit of their popularity both in their own countries and abroad. Another (and I believe key) flaw is that while he criticizes many of the political myths or fantasies in the region for, among other things, promoting a simplistic manichean world view, he falls prey to this himself in the sense that he portrays the West, liberalism and the market economy as absolutes which must be attained by all former communist societies. Rarely are the concepts of liberal democracy and capitalism discussed as political myths themselves (regardless of their validity), and Tismaneanu never even entertains the notion that grafting such idealized concepts onto the post-socialist societies may be yet another cause for their often staggering economic and social problems. This really takes away from some of the top-notch analysis in this book, for at times it seems less of a scholarly work than an ideological tract.


Only For The Truly InterestedThe book does detail out some of the successes of the World War Two counter intelligence and intelligence gathering operations and the creation of the new German organization. It goes into some detail of the "battles" between the East German intelligence and the West German group, some of which is interesting. We also get some interesting stories about people escaping from East Germany. The down side to the book is that it is dry. You can tell the book was translated because there is a distinct lack of wit or pep. I think the reader of this book really have to be interested in German Cold War intelligence gathering stories, the general read would not get past page 100.


A useful contribution to the history of Germans in CanadaGrams, a native of Saskatchewan, appears to be a very earnest and meticulous researcher, and the book is valuable for leading the reader, through its nearly 1700 footnotes, to a vast array of archival materials. Its shortcomings, and they are fairly serious, lie in the realm of organization and the use of the English language. It suffers a good deal from repetition, but even more so from grammatical, syntactical and stylistic errors. This may have something to do with its being a dissertation for a German university (Marburg), plus a woeful lack of editing before it went to print. Whatever the cause, keeping one's mind on the subject matter and off the mistakes requires a bit of an effort, reducing it from a four-star book to three stars. All in all, however, the effort is worth it.


Decent But Superficial AccountWashington's achievements were primarily in three areas: commanding the continental army, being president of the Constitutional Convention, and serving as the country's first President. He practically single-handedly fostered a sense of our being one united country and held it together through the war, the draftig of the Constitution, and the national's early history.
It is difficult to overestimate Washington's contributions. Everything he did set a precedent for the nation. And everything was being done for the first time. There had been no democratic country in the history of the world. No country had had a democratically elected leader; they had all been kings.
Washington was a fascinating man. Unfortunately, this book is not. Still, it is worthwhile as a superficial overview of Washington's life.


Ageing the hard way

A Solid Biography - but lacking in the excitement of the manMany rightly raved about Mirka Zemanova's previous contribution to the Janacek bibliography, her edition of the composer's uncollected essays on musicology. The volume included many previously unseen, or at least untranslated pieces of writing by Janacek. Various reviews of performances in Brno for the local journals and newspapers were enlightening when considering the many influences on Janacek's own writing, the Brno premieres of Cavalleria Rusticana or Tchaikovsky's Queen of Spades influencing Janacek's Jenufa, for example. Many passages have seeped their way into recent writing about the composer's life and works with the same regularity as quotes from John Tyrrell's many documentary translations, the letters to Kamila Stosslova particularly.
Zemanova has decided to eschew use of Tyrrell's great translations of the letters and various documents, and returned to the original sources, itself not a bad idea. For the English speaking Janacek fan though, perhaps more cross references to those masterly volumes wouldn't have been too bad a thing, and her dismissal of some of Tyrrell's work is misplaced. Zemanova has great command of her material at best, but occasionally she is rather prosaic on a life that was so lacking in humdrum. Her outlining of details of the Vienna premiere of Jenufa, rather than dwelling on the Prague premiere (itself very important, but perhaps a little too glorified in recent literature) is to be commended. Her scatty musical analysis is a disappointment. Although she outlines her concern with focussing less on the 'works' and more on the 'life', her style is not always up to the dramatics of Janacek's life. I would recommend a reading of the composer's wife's memoirs for some of the real drama.
It is a mixed book, fitting for such a mixed man, filled with facts that weren't available to previous biographers, but lacking in the grasp of some other regular contributors to Janacek literature. Hopefully, however, it will be the first of a stream of issues about this fascinating composer in the year leading up to the 150th anniversary of his birth, and the 100th anniversary of the premiere of his first great opera Jenufa.
There is, though, a very laughable introduction to the constitution written by the translator at the beginning of the text. That introduction should only be considered valuable if one wants to study the "spin" of the revolutionaries.
Nice, simple, exact work. Perfect as a textbook or sourcebook for reference.